In the story Jane Eyre, if Jane could be described as any adjective, she would be the closest to these two: persistent, and strong willed. Jane’s persistence and strong will are what aid her into becoming the woman she eventually becomes. Yes Jane may seem like a plain and ordinary girl, but she definitely has some command and power. She knows when enough is enough and when it is a time to take a stand against things. She knows not to give in to guilt or temptation and is obstinate in the most impressive way.
Right of the bat when Jane is a mere child, she demonstrates her strong will when she explodes in front of Mrs. Reed after her conversation with Mr. Brocklehurst about Lowood school. Jane defies Mrs. Reed and taking control over her says:
“I am glad you are no relation of mine: I will never call you aunt again as long as I live. I will never come to see you when I am grown up; and if any one asks me how I liked you, and how you treated me, I will say the very thought of you makes me sick, and that you treated me with miserable cruelty’ (49).
Jane truly sets off Mrs. Reed so much that she doesn’t even know what to say. Jane senses the right time to stand up for herself and does it defiantly and strong willingly. Another example illustrating Jane’s strong will is during her time with St. John when he tells her of her fortune and she does not want him to leave yet because she wants to know more. St. John says to her:
“But I apprised you that I was a hard man…Difficult to persuade” (576). Jane retorts: “And I am a hard woman, - impossible to put off” (576). St. John comes back with: “And then, I am cold: no fervour infects me” (576) and Jane yet again defies him and says: “Whereas I am hot, and fire dissolves ice” (576).
This little verbal argument Jane and St. John share directly shows Jane’s strong will and persistence with being the one who comes out on top. She makes herself superior to St. John; she shows him who he is up against.
These are very important values/qualities seen in Jane Eyre as they act as the framework for what kind of person Jane really is and how she establishes herself in society. In society today, it doesn’t seem like we have a problem with this. We see strong will and persistence everywhere: in school, on the sports field, at home. It seems as though everyone is grounded with strong will and persistence but there are specific moments in our lives where they are clearly brought out.
When/where do you think people show the most strong will and persistence?
Thursday, November 19, 2009
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Usury and Objectifying
Throughout the book of Jane Eyre, usury of men and women was utilized by many characters. Rochester used Blanche Ingram to make Jane feel jealous. In attempts to force Jane into confessing her feelings for him: "I feigned courtship of Miss Ingram, because I wished to render you as madly in love with me as I was with you." (392).
Rochester was not the only selfish one; the relationship between Miss Ingram and Rochester was built off of mutual selfishness. If the two were to have married, Miss Ingram would have become rich: her goal from the start. Rochester explains Ingram's self centered plan to Jane:"I caused a rumor to reach her that my fortune was not a third of what was supposed, and after that ... it was coldness both from her and her mother." (392)
Marriages were often built off of using the spouse as an object to gain wealth or a higher social class.
St. John, the righteous missionary, did not act like one, when trying to force Jane to marry him. St. John was set on reaching heaven, therefore, he did not sustain relationships with women: even the woman he deeply loved, "When I colour, and when I shake before Miss Oliver, I do not pity myself. I scorn the weakness." (562).
Instead, St. John attempts to marry Jane, a religious women, who he thinks would be the right choice in the eyes of God. His usury of Jane to reach heaven is illustrated here:
"It is not personal, but endowments they have given you: you are formed for labour, not for love. A missionary's wife you must - shall be. You shall be mine: I claim you - not for my pleasure, but for my Sovereign's service."
St. John's words are so clear they almost don't need explanation. St. John is clearly saying "hey look I don't really love you, but you would be perfect to help me 'get the job' ". The "job" meaning reaching heaven through missionary work.
I believe marriages have greatly evolved from the historical marriages, where the only reason was for self benefit, not love. For example, the story of Titanic. In Titanic, Rose, the daughter of a wealthy family, marries Jack, a poor working class guy, despite his poor background and her parents disapproval.
Rochester was not the only selfish one; the relationship between Miss Ingram and Rochester was built off of mutual selfishness. If the two were to have married, Miss Ingram would have become rich: her goal from the start. Rochester explains Ingram's self centered plan to Jane:"I caused a rumor to reach her that my fortune was not a third of what was supposed, and after that ... it was coldness both from her and her mother." (392)
Marriages were often built off of using the spouse as an object to gain wealth or a higher social class.
St. John, the righteous missionary, did not act like one, when trying to force Jane to marry him. St. John was set on reaching heaven, therefore, he did not sustain relationships with women: even the woman he deeply loved, "When I colour, and when I shake before Miss Oliver, I do not pity myself. I scorn the weakness." (562).
Instead, St. John attempts to marry Jane, a religious women, who he thinks would be the right choice in the eyes of God. His usury of Jane to reach heaven is illustrated here:
"It is not personal, but endowments they have given you: you are formed for labour, not for love. A missionary's wife you must - shall be. You shall be mine: I claim you - not for my pleasure, but for my Sovereign's service."
St. John's words are so clear they almost don't need explanation. St. John is clearly saying "hey look I don't really love you, but you would be perfect to help me 'get the job' ". The "job" meaning reaching heaven through missionary work.
I believe marriages have greatly evolved from the historical marriages, where the only reason was for self benefit, not love. For example, the story of Titanic. In Titanic, Rose, the daughter of a wealthy family, marries Jack, a poor working class guy, despite his poor background and her parents disapproval.
Sunday, November 15, 2009
Independence
Throughout Jane Eyre the character Jane has always been independent of herself. Jane’s early life in a hostile environment really shaped her into becoming an independent girl at a very early age. As stated before, she had no family. Jane’s independence only grew stronger throughout her life and seemed most prevalent with Jane’s time with St. John; this happens specifically in chapter 29. Jane is grateful for the hospitality she is given at the Moor House but announces her wish to leave and partake in things on her own. St. John says to Jane:
“You would not like to be long dependent on our hospitality – you would wish, I see, to dispense as soon as may be with my sisters’ compassion; and, above all, with my charity…You desire to be independent of us?” (522) and Jane replies strongly with, “I do: I have already said so. Show me how to work, or how to seek work: that is all I ask; then let me go…” (522).
The character of Jane can be depicted as a woman of independence and individuality; these values distinguish who Jane really is and describe what motives she has. These values can be related somewhat to romanticism because one of the focuses of this type of writing is on the individual rather than society.
We have learned that the Renaissance was a time where creativity bloomed and independency and individuality were pervasive throughout the country of Europe as well as in the 18th century with the colonists’ desire to become independent from Great Britain. Throughout history, we can clearly see which points of time have been most independent and can easily make a connection to today’s society where independency is omnipresent though not as concentrated compared to these occasions. In society today, independency is everywhere: artists, musicians, philosophical thinkers, and even everyday school kids are just a few to name.
What are your feelings on independency in society today compared to what we have read in Jane Eyre?
“You would not like to be long dependent on our hospitality – you would wish, I see, to dispense as soon as may be with my sisters’ compassion; and, above all, with my charity…You desire to be independent of us?” (522) and Jane replies strongly with, “I do: I have already said so. Show me how to work, or how to seek work: that is all I ask; then let me go…” (522).
The character of Jane can be depicted as a woman of independence and individuality; these values distinguish who Jane really is and describe what motives she has. These values can be related somewhat to romanticism because one of the focuses of this type of writing is on the individual rather than society.
We have learned that the Renaissance was a time where creativity bloomed and independency and individuality were pervasive throughout the country of Europe as well as in the 18th century with the colonists’ desire to become independent from Great Britain. Throughout history, we can clearly see which points of time have been most independent and can easily make a connection to today’s society where independency is omnipresent though not as concentrated compared to these occasions. In society today, independency is everywhere: artists, musicians, philosophical thinkers, and even everyday school kids are just a few to name.
What are your feelings on independency in society today compared to what we have read in Jane Eyre?
Family
Jane grew up in a home and with her family members, yet they treated her like a servant; she never had a real family. However, as the plot develops, Jane finds the family she has been longing for. Her excitement in the discovery is illustrated here."This was a blessing, bright, vivid, and exhilarating; - not like the ponderous gift of gold: rich and welcoming enough in its way..." (p. 579).
Jane then uses her fortune to reunite the family and enjoys their company always. Jane embraces and feels fortunate to have what most people take for granted. From personal experience I know that families rarely give one another money, and that it can be a subject of sensitivity between them. Of the family finances, inheritance is typically the most fought over. Jane selflessly evenly distributed the 20,000 pounds among her family just to keep them close. How often do families do that for one another? There are advantages to being close to your family: families can be a great support group, you can enjoy the company of people who really love you, and families don't tend to judge like peers do. Jane Eyre really shows the positive side of keeping in close contact with family.
Jane then uses her fortune to reunite the family and enjoys their company always. Jane embraces and feels fortunate to have what most people take for granted. From personal experience I know that families rarely give one another money, and that it can be a subject of sensitivity between them. Of the family finances, inheritance is typically the most fought over. Jane selflessly evenly distributed the 20,000 pounds among her family just to keep them close. How often do families do that for one another? There are advantages to being close to your family: families can be a great support group, you can enjoy the company of people who really love you, and families don't tend to judge like peers do. Jane Eyre really shows the positive side of keeping in close contact with family.
Living a Modest Lifestyle
One prominent theme we see while reading Jane Eyre is the value in living a modest lifestyle. We see this a lot with Jane throughout her experiences with various characters; it is established that she is a very plain girl. An example of where this theme of living a modest lifestyle is most eminent is after Mr. Rochester and Jane admit that they love each other; subsequently deciding to get married. Mr. Rochester tells Jane of all the dresses and jewels he will get for her and Jane refuses a little indignantly.
Rochester says, "This morning I wrote to my banker in London to send me certain jewels he has in his keeping,...In a day or two I hope to put them into your lap: for every privilege, every attention shall be yours..." (386). Jane responds with, "Oh, sir! - never mind jewels! I don't like to hear them spoken of. Jewels for Jane Eyre sounds unnatural and strange; I would rather not have them" (386) and later responds to Rochester by saying, "Don't send for the jewels and don't crown me with roses: you might as well put a border of lace round that plain pocket-handkerchief you have there" (390).
These passages illustrate Jane's desire for living a modest lifestyle and her dislike of material things. She asks Rochester,
“I would much rather have all your confidence. You will not exclude me from your confidence, if you admit me to your heart?” (391).
This shows Jane’s wish for truth and confidence in Rochester rather than him simply buying her things. This part of the story really exemplifies the quote, “Money can’t buy love” huh? She later goes on to say,
“I had rather be a thing than an angel” (391).
This quote all the more demonstrates Jane’s wish to live a simple and modest life without excess flattery as Stephen posted before, and her desire for honesty and confidence as opposed to just material things.
When we look at society now, it seems as though we have lost these values of living a plain and modest life. Our lives have been cluttered with processed things; it’s as though we only desire more and more. We only care about the newest thing and don’t pay attention to what beautiful things we already possess in our hearts: the values of truth, modesty, confidence, and honesty.
Rochester says, "This morning I wrote to my banker in London to send me certain jewels he has in his keeping,...In a day or two I hope to put them into your lap: for every privilege, every attention shall be yours..." (386). Jane responds with, "Oh, sir! - never mind jewels! I don't like to hear them spoken of. Jewels for Jane Eyre sounds unnatural and strange; I would rather not have them" (386) and later responds to Rochester by saying, "Don't send for the jewels and don't crown me with roses: you might as well put a border of lace round that plain pocket-handkerchief you have there" (390).
These passages illustrate Jane's desire for living a modest lifestyle and her dislike of material things. She asks Rochester,
“I would much rather have all your confidence. You will not exclude me from your confidence, if you admit me to your heart?” (391).
This shows Jane’s wish for truth and confidence in Rochester rather than him simply buying her things. This part of the story really exemplifies the quote, “Money can’t buy love” huh? She later goes on to say,
“I had rather be a thing than an angel” (391).
This quote all the more demonstrates Jane’s wish to live a simple and modest life without excess flattery as Stephen posted before, and her desire for honesty and confidence as opposed to just material things.
When we look at society now, it seems as though we have lost these values of living a plain and modest life. Our lives have been cluttered with processed things; it’s as though we only desire more and more. We only care about the newest thing and don’t pay attention to what beautiful things we already possess in our hearts: the values of truth, modesty, confidence, and honesty.
Flattery and Modesty
As I was reading chapter 24, I noticed how much Jane values equality in a relationship.
" 'I will make the world acknowledge you a beauty too, ' he went on, while I really became uneasy at the strain he had adopted; because I felt he was either deluding himself, or trying to delude me ... ' I love you most dearly far too dearly to flatter you. Don't flatter me.' " (p. 387)
Throughout the story Jane has shown her love for Rochester through respect, and Rochester had returned the favor. To Jane, flattery does not show respect but a tool that can cause belittlement. Jane stresses equality and respect; welcoming flattery would not put her on Rochester's level. For all the women out there looking to be their man's social equal, don't fall for their flattery; falling for flattery shows need for approval. If you are already equal then why do you need approval from your equal? Jane knows she is intellectually and socially equal; she refuses to bring herself down a level by allowing Rochester to constantly compliment her. The following quote properly describes Jane's feelings towards flattery.
"...and I like rudeness a great deal better than flattery. I had rather be a thing than an angel." (p. 391)
" 'I will make the world acknowledge you a beauty too, ' he went on, while I really became uneasy at the strain he had adopted; because I felt he was either deluding himself, or trying to delude me ... ' I love you most dearly far too dearly to flatter you. Don't flatter me.' " (p. 387)
Throughout the story Jane has shown her love for Rochester through respect, and Rochester had returned the favor. To Jane, flattery does not show respect but a tool that can cause belittlement. Jane stresses equality and respect; welcoming flattery would not put her on Rochester's level. For all the women out there looking to be their man's social equal, don't fall for their flattery; falling for flattery shows need for approval. If you are already equal then why do you need approval from your equal? Jane knows she is intellectually and socially equal; she refuses to bring herself down a level by allowing Rochester to constantly compliment her. The following quote properly describes Jane's feelings towards flattery.
"...and I like rudeness a great deal better than flattery. I had rather be a thing than an angel." (p. 391)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)